The right to refuse to answer a question in court

Information

If you are giving evidence (either during the examination or the cross-examination) in a court in Ireland, and you do not wish to answer a particular question, you must indicate to the judge that you are not prepared to answer the question and why.

Rules

There are very few circumstances where a judge will allow you to refuse to answer a question if it is relevant to the case. The right to refuse is known as a privilege:

  • You have a "privilege against self-incrimination". This means that you can refuse to answer questions or hand over documents that may implicate you in criminal proceedings.
  • You may have a "legal professional privilege". A legal advisor and his or her client cannot be forced to disclose communications between them. If any communication is made in contemplation of litigation (i.e., with a court case in mind), then that communication is also privileged.
  • Priests are allowed to refuse to answer questions relating to what was said in the confessional. This is known as the "sacerdotal privilege". Similarly, communications with a counsellor may also be privileged.

When you have voiced your objection to answering a particular question, the judge will then decide whether you or not you must answer the question. If the judge decides that you cannot rely on a "privilege", then you must answer the question. If you fail to do so, you will be in contempt of court and you may be imprisoned.

Page updated: 11 September 2008

Categories

Social Welfare

Employment

Education and Training

Travel and Recreation

Housing

Moving Country

Money and Tax

Family and Relationships

Health

Justice

Consumer Affairs

Death and Bereavement

Government in Ireland

Environment

Find a Citizens Information Centre

Accessibility

Privacy

Contact us

Disclaimer

Re-use of Public Sector Information